Thanks everyone! I have plenty of time to solve this riddle and I do enjoy a challenge. I wish it was Ivans Paddle, but I am skeptical.
@cpbobby: these are in fact plants I got from you in a trade and there was to be a collins in there. When I got the package tho you had thought it was the second biggest plant that was collins. That plant got frosted in the mail. These little guys were almost giving me the impression of stow aways. They were teensy, maybe 1/4" tall and wide. You said you had sent back extra plants that I had sent you, which could only have been adelae or fraser isl. spat. I don't recall all of the details, but I remember you sent a little regia, nidiformis, and the one that died which was probably not collins (it was a very tightly rosetted plant that best I could tell reminded me of slackii or maybe admirabilis shaped) and a few others which would be tough to confuse. (bladderworts etc.) So yeah, as far as the trade was concerned, it must be either collins or a mystery stow-away. Either way I am glad to have it! Thanks again.