The second lizard was dead...or at least I thought so. It didn't move when I shook the pitcher to see if it would react.
I had been smelling something odd at my balcony lately and I suppose it came from the pitchers. The North wind is blowing right into my living area...if I don't remove the pitchers, my entire apartment would stink! I could have just emptied the contents and keep the pitchers but it's quite alright with me to lose them. At least they have been immortalised in this thread.