That's a tough call. If they were the same price, I'd choose the red hairy Nepenthes hamata. Chien Lee's photo is the finest Nepenthes pic I've seen. But, the Nepenthes edwardsiana (eddie) is so much cheaper. However, I've never been that enthralled with Nepenthes edwardsiana. I like Nepenthes villosa much more. If I had the conditions, I'd put Nepenthes villosa right below red Nepenthes hamata for my most wanted.