mobile, I absolutely agree with you. Certainly, I have tried a lot of things at least once that I have read from here. While I have noticed no harm and seen growth, it's never clear if what I tried made the growth better or worse since I never have a control. Any comments I make on the matter will usually come in the form of, 'I tried it, and didn't notice any ill affect.'
Whatever we may think about certain things like superthrive, coffee, milk, etc... to pass judgment without ever giving it a shot seems a bit asinine, but to each his own.
Anyway, sorry for derailing this thread.