[b said:
Quote[/b] (Tropics @ April 11 2005,11:26)]I also live in the subtropics, and I’ve been gathering information about the needs of CPs for cold weather and/or short photoperiods to initiate dormancy. From what I gather, VTSs have to be put in the refrigerator for dormancy in a subtropical climate. Otherwise they get weaker in successive years and eventually die. However, many Sarrs don’t need it.
I’ve kept Sarrs for a couple of years now without putting them in the refrigerator (mainly because I’m lazy). They stop growing during the winter, but in the spring they start growing again. Mine are coming out of dormancy now, and they are as tall as they were when I originally got them. A TerraForums member from Florida says he lets the growing medium get drier during the winter, and somehow that seems to help. I think I’ll try that next winter.
Anyhow, those who say Sarrs need cold weather and/or short photoperiods during winter may be well intentioned, but are misinformed. Maybe some expert said it way back when, and since then it’s been repeated so often that it’s now “common knowledge,” although based on erroneous assumptions rather than practical experience. After all, nobody is 100 percent right all the time
Most Sarrs are native to the southeastern part of the United States, where winters are relatively mild. So it’s not a big leap to survive in a subtropical climate. (The species that may have difficulty is S. purpurea because it is native to the northern U.S.) You’re probably aware of other plants native to temperate climates that can grow outdoors all year in the subtropics. They may not grow as large, but they can grow and even thrive.
Unfortunately, I believe that this misinformation about Sarrs needing cold and/or short photoperiods for dormancy has discouraged many people from even trying to grow them in the subtropics because they didn’t want the extra bother. Too bad.
actually,
you are misinformed,
sarrs needing dormancy is not a myth, it is very real.
if you have only kept sarrs alive "for a couple years" without dormancy then you arent really qualified to say if they need it or not.
try keeping them alive for 10 years without dormancy then get back to us!
[b said:
Quote[/b] ]From what I gather, VTSs have to be put in the refrigerator for dormancy in a subtropical climate. Otherwise they get weaker in successive years and eventually die. However, many Sarrs don’t need it.
yes, they do need it.
[b said:
Quote[/b] ]They stop growing during the winter, but in the spring they start growing again.
that IS dormancy!!
you are giving your sarrs a winter dormancy.
[b said:
Quote[/b] ]Anyhow, those who say Sarrs need cold weather and/or short photoperiods during winter may be well intentioned, but are misinformed. Maybe some expert said it way back when, and since then it’s been repeated so often that it’s now “common knowledge,” although based on erroneous assumptions rather than practical experience. After all, nobody is 100 percent right all the time
wrong wrong wrong.
the "need" for winter dormancy wasnt "made up" by a few "well-intentioned but misinformed" people.
the need for dormancy comes from millions of years of evolution and the native climate of the plants.
Try putting a Canadian maple tree in brazil and see how long it lasts.
or a cactus in the amazon rainforest.
or plant a sarracenia in the sands of the sahara desert.
it wont work.
its the sanme with dormancy..no one made this stuff up!
its just nature..you cant change these rules and expect the plants to live.
sarrs have specific requirements they need to live.
pure water.
high light.
low-nutrient growing media.
winter dormancy.
why do they need all those things?
because thats the emvironment they have been growin in for millions of years.
no one is going to change that anytime soon.
yes there is a somewhat wide range of conditions they can tolorate, but NO dormancy at all is definately outside that range.
of course, we need to define what "dormancy" really means..
yes, Sarrs "go dormant" in the wild in northern Florida and Georgia, where winters are very mild.
but..they still slow down or stop growing, the temps get much cooler than in the summer, and the photoperiod gets much less..(naturally less light in winter)
there is a HUGE difference between winter in Georgia and winter on the equator.
yes, "winter in Georgia" isnt much of a winter compared to "winter in Canada", but its still winter, and its still cool enough and dark enough to put the plants into a true dormancy.
you can probably sucessfully put sarrs into dormancy outdoors in the winter in florida.
but you cant in Mexico, or Brazil, or anywhere closer to the equator that mid-florida.
(has anyone ever wondered why sarrs dont grow wild into middle and southern florida? very boggy down there right?
seems like an ideal climate for them right?
well its not..
they probably dont grow there because its too warm for them..they cant survive.)
the real key for sarr dormancy is LESS light and LOWER temps in the winter than in the summer..
(and letting the media go slightly drier is helpfull too.)
if your native winters arent much different that summer, then thats not good enough.
if you dont have native decidious trees that drop their leaves in the autumn, then its too warm for sarr dormancy outdoors.
personally, I would want at least 50 degree winter days as the absolute warmest.
(10-15 degrees Celcius)
anythign warmer that that is TOO warm IMO.
if your winters are generally warmer than 50F 10C, you should do something else for dormancy..the fridge or something else to keep them cool.
SAcarnivore,
here is how I do the fridge dormancy.
I have the opposite problem from you, winters that are far too cold!
http://home.petflytrap.com/users....05.html
Scot